Dockery’s book on complementarianism provides conversation among adherents

Row rect Shape Decorative svg added to top
Dr. David Dockery faculty book talk on Complimentarianism

President David S. Dockery discussed his recent edited work, Complementarianism: A Continuum of Perspectives on Men and Women in the Church, during a Sept. 17 event at Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary, encouraging students and other Christians to exhibit respect and a Christ-like spirit with others who do not hold the same perspective they do on the topic.

“We need to understand how to talk about these issues, talk about them well, talk about them with kindness,” Dockery said during the book talk hosted by the School of Theology and the Land Center for Cultural Engagement at Southwestern. “To exercise our own core values here at Southwestern, to be grace filled and Christ centered, in how we talk about these things, and do so with a great deal of respect, even where there might be nuances of difference, and allow for those differences.”

Dockery said he was approached by B&H Academic and Lifeway Christian Resources leadership concerning the project in 2024. The book was released in June and includes six perspectives within the complementarian continuum, as shared by contributors including Gregg Allison, Dondi Costin, Julia Higgins, Kristen Kellen, Glenn Kreider, John Stonestreet, Erik Thoennes, Dani Treweek, and Ray Van Neste.

Dockery explained that those who hold to complementarianism believe men and women are equal in their creation, salvation, and reception of spiritual gifts, but that they are different in how they are designed and gifted for some aspects of service. Egalitarians hold that the roles of men and women are equal in the church without limitations pertaining to gender.

Beyond those views, Dockery said there are what he refers to as non-evangelical egalitarians who believe the Scripture is wrong or outdated when it speaks of the roles of men and women in the church. Beyond these views on the left are feminist theologians and some on the right who affirm a patriarchal position.

President David S. Dockery’s book on complementarianism is available for purchase.

Even within the complementarian stance, Dockery said there are differences in opinion on whether women can teach men and if women can serve the church in the role of the deacon. But all agree that a woman should not hold a position as senior pastor.

Dockery pointed out a number of women who are mentioned in both the Old Testament and the New Testament, such as Deborah, Miriam, Esther, Lydia, Mary Magdalene, and Joanna. But in the New Testament, he said there is no mention of a woman given the title of elder nor was there a woman among the twelve apostles.

“Women are called to serve,” Dockery said. “And women are gifted with spiritual gifts that need to be developed so that they can be used in key roles of service.”

While many Baptists are complementarian, Dockery said the book is not limited to Baptists alone, and includes contributors from other denominations, providing a “robust, healthy conversation” of an important matter, although less so than the deity of Christ or other core doctrines.

“In the broader picture of Christianity, this question is clearly a secondary, or sometimes even a tertiary, question,” Dockery said, while pointing out that in some denominations it is given much more weight.

Though it is important to discern when there should be separation between churches and denominations because of differing beliefs, Dockery said conversations on the topic should be held from a place of humility, recognizing it is possible to have a wrong interpretation of the inerrant Scripture. Kindness and respect for others should also be present, even when there is disagreement.

“I think it’s very helpful and informative to see, even in the book, that people can disagree respectfully,” Dockery said. “I think that’s an important thing for all of us to learn how to do, is to agree and disagree with still having respect for those with whom we have disagreement.”